25 Vintage Candy Recipes

Published: Sep 8, 2025 by Jessica @ TMG · This post may contain affiliate links · Leave a Comment

If you grew up in the 70s and 80s like I did, chances are you remember the joy of homemade candy around the holidays. Grandma would have pans of fudge cooling on the counter, popcorn balls wrapped in wax paper, and tins of peanut brittle ready for Christmas guests. These weren’t fancy store-bought chocolates—they were simple, homemade sweets passed around at church socials, weddings, and family gatherings.

This collection of 25 vintage candy recipes will take you right back to those cozy, nostalgic days. From creamy fudge and pralines to no-bake haystacks and candy you actually had to “pull,” these are the sweets that made childhood (and grandma’s kitchen) so special.

25 Vintage Candy Recipes

1

Easy Chocolate Fudge

Easy Chocolate Fudge

Rich, creamy squares made with sugar, butter, and chocolate. First appearing in the late 1800s, fudge became a mainstay in mid-20th-century kitchens and holiday tins.

Check out this recipe

2

Old Fashioned Penuche Fudge Recipe - Tasty Ever After

Old Fashioned Penuche Fudge Recipe - Tasty Ever After

Buttery fudge flavored with brown sugar for a caramel-like taste. A New England favorite since the 19th century, often sold at church bazaars and fairs.

Check out this recipe

3

Caramel Squares

Caramel Squares

Soft and chewy, made with sugar, butter, and cream. Homemade caramels were especially popular in the early 1900s as holiday gifts.

Check out this recipe

4

Maple Candy

Pure maple syrup cooked into melt-in-your-mouth candies. A regional favorite in New England and Canada, especially during sugaring season.

Check out this recipe

5

Easy Opera Cream Candies

Easy Opera Cream Candies

Smooth, creamy candy often flavored with vanilla or almond. Popular in Pennsylvania and the Midwest in the early 20th century, sold in candy shops and passed down in family cookbooks.

Check out this recipe

6

Peanut Brittle Recipe

Peanut Brittle Recipe

Thin, crisp candy made with peanuts, sugar, and butter. A Depression-era favorite, it was inexpensive and perfect for filling Christmas tins.

Check out this recipe

7

Seafoam Candy Recipe

Seafoam Candy Recipe

Crunchy and airy with a caramelized flavor, made by whipping baking soda into sugar syrup. A fairground and candy shop favorite in the 1920s–40s.

Check out this recipe

8

Kentucky Cream Pull Candy

Kentucky Cream Pull Candy

Chewy candy flavored with fruit or vanilla, pulled until glossy. Popular in the late 1800s–early 1900s, “taffy pulls” were a fun family or community activity.

Check out this recipe

9

Pulled Molasses Taffy

Pulled Molasses Taffy

Chewy molasses-based candy pulled until shiny and firm. A farmhouse treat in the late 1800s–early 1900s, especially in rural kitchens where molasses was plentiful.

Check out this recipe

10

The Best Honeycomb Recipe (Easy honeycomb candy)

The Best Honeycomb Recipe (Easy honeycomb candy)

Crisp, bubbly candy with a caramelized honey flavor. Homemade versions appeared in the 1920s–40s, often called sponge candy or cinder toffee.

Check out this recipe

11

Old-Fashioned Divinity Candy Recipe

Old-Fashioned Divinity Candy Recipe

Fluffy, nougat-like candy made with whipped egg whites, sugar, and corn syrup. Popular in the early 1900s, it became a Southern Christmas tradition.

Check out this recipe

12

Old Fashioned Southern Pecan Praline Recipe - Butter & Baggage

Old Fashioned Southern Pecan Praline Recipe - Butter & Baggage

Creamy, caramel-like candies loaded with pecans. A New Orleans specialty dating back to the 19th century, they became a beloved Southern holiday candy.

Check out this recipe

13

Chocolate Covered Cherries

Chocolate Covered Cherries

Whole cherries dipped in chocolate with a sweet liquid or cream center. A mid-century holiday classic, often homemade for Christmas platters.

Check out this recipe

14

Peppermint Bark with Peppermint Dust | Alexandra’s Kitchen

Peppermint Bark with Peppermint Dust | Alexandra’s Kitchen

Layers of white and dark chocolate topped with crushed candy canes. Became especially trendy in the mid-20th century as a Christmas candy.

Check out this recipe

15

No Bake Coconut Snowballs Recipe

No Bake Coconut Snowballs Recipe

Chocolate or marshmallow centers rolled in coconut. A mid-century Christmas tradition often tucked into cookie tins.

Check out this recipe

16

Cream Cheese Mints

Cream Cheese Mints

Soft, melt-in-your-mouth mints made with cream cheese and powdered sugar. Popular in the 1950s–70s at weddings, showers, and holiday gatherings.

Check out this recipe

17

Best Butter Mints (Homemade)

Best Butter Mints (Homemade)

Pastel-colored candies that melt away with a creamy mint flavor. A staple at weddings and church socials throughout the 1950s–70s.

Check out this recipe

18

No-Bake Peanut Butter Potato Candy • All that’s Jas

No-Bake Peanut Butter Potato Candy • All that’s Jas

Mashed potatoes mixed with powdered sugar, rolled with peanut butter, and sliced. A thrifty Depression-era recipe that turned humble ingredients into a sweet treat.

Check out this recipe

19

Making Homemade Fudge With Mashed Potatoes! - Our Wren’s Nest

Making Homemade Fudge With Mashed Potatoes! - Our Wren’s Nest

Another potato-based candy blended with cocoa and sugar. An Irish-American favorite that thrived in Depression-era kitchens.

Check out this recipe

20

Rock Candy

Rock Candy

Sugar crystals grown on strings or sticks. A simple homemade project that delighted children for generations.

Check out this recipe

21

Haystacks Recipe

Haystacks Recipe

Chow mein noodles or cornflakes coated in melted butterscotch or chocolate. A no-bake 1960s–70s classic, especially at bake sales and church events.

Check out this recipe

22

Martha Washington Candy

Martha Washington Candy

Creamy coconut and pecan filling dipped in chocolate. Popular in the early 20th century and often handed down in family cookbooks as a holiday favorite.

Check out this recipe

23

Peanut Clusters Recipe, Easy, 3-Ingredient & Delicious

Peanut Clusters Recipe, Easy, 3-Ingredient & Delicious

Simple candies made by coating peanuts with melted chocolate or butterscotch. A no-fuss mid-century candy often found in cookie tins and bake sales.

Check out this recipe

24

Marshmallow Nougat: Easy Homemade Microwave Recipe!

Marshmallow Nougat: Easy Homemade Microwave Recipe!

Nougat is such a fun treat that’s perfect for the holidays! It’s denser than a marshmallow but softer than fudge, and loaded with gumdrops for a festive sweet.

Check out this recipe

25

Easy Peanut Butter Fudge

Easy Peanut Butter Fudge

Creamy, rich, and melt-in-your-mouth, this old-fashioned peanut butter fudge is a vintage favorite that tastes just like grandma used to make.

Check out this recipe

Wrap-Up

Vintage candy wasn’t just about the sweets—it was about the traditions that came with them. Whether it was pulling taffy as a family, pouring peanut brittle onto a buttered sheet pan, or rolling divinity into fluffy white bites at Christmas, these recipes connect us to generations past. The best part? They’re just as delightful to make today.

FAQs About Vintage Candy

What makes candy “vintage”?

Vintage candy recipes are the ones passed down through generations, especially those popular between the late 1800s and mid-20th century.

Why was homemade candy so popular?

Store-bought candy was expensive or unavailable in many areas, so families made their own sweets for holidays, weddings, and church socials.

Can I make these vintage candies today?

Yes! Most adapt perfectly with modern ingredients and equipment, though you may need a candy thermometer for accuracy.

Which vintage candy is the most nostalgic?

Fudge and peanut brittle are two of the most widely remembered, but divinity and potato candy often hold the deepest family memories.

Are these candies hard to make?

Some require precision with sugar stages, but many—like haystacks, potato candy, or peanut clusters—are quick and beginner-friendly.

More Old Fashioned Recipe Collections

Leave a Reply Cancel reply