10 Vintage Heart Cakes

If you grew up in the 70s or 80s like I did, you probably remember the excitement of seeing a heart-shaped cake appear on the table. Grandma didn’t need fancy bakery tricks to make something special—just a heart pan (or a clever way of cutting a round and square cake together), a can of frosting, and maybe a handful of sprinkles. These cakes weren’t just desserts—they were symbols of love, whether baked for Valentine’s Day, an anniversary, or just to make a family dinner feel extra sweet.

This collection of 10 vintage heart cake recipes brings back all those cozy memories. From old-fashioned chocolate hearts to pastel party cakes and Jell-O-era favorites, these are the retro recipes that made bake sales, potlucks, and Valentine’s Day unforgettable.

Vintage Heart Cakes

1

Chocolate Heart Cake - Texanerin Baking

Moist chocolate cake baked in a heart pan or cut into shape, topped with chocolate frosting. A mid-century favorite that took off in the 1950s–60s when novelty pans and boxed mixes made it easy to create festive shapes at home.

Check out this recipe

2

Angel Food Cake Heart

Airy angel food cake baked in a heart pan and topped with glaze or berries. Popular in the 1950s–60s when lighter desserts were fashionable for spring holidays.

Check out this recipe

3

Mini Chocolate Peanut Butter Icebox Cakes – The Desserted Girl

Graham crackers or ladyfingers layered with your favorite flavor of cream or pudding, chilled in a heart mold. A 1930s–50s favorite when refrigerator cakes were trendy and convenient.

Check out this recipe

4

Heritage Red Velvet Cake - Sprinkle Bakes

Cocoa-kissed red velvet cake layered with cream cheese or ermine frosting. This elegant cake became a romantic staple in the 1940s–50s and was perfect for anniversaries and Valentine’s dinners.

Check out this recipe

5

Fresh Strawberry Heart Cake

A pink, strawberry-flavored cake layered with whipped cream or cream cheese frosting. Hugely popular in the 1960s–70s, often made with Jell-O to enhance flavor and color.

Check out this recipe

6

Heart Coconut Cake

White cake frosted and generously covered with coconut flakes. A Southern tradition since the early 1900s, coconut cakes became especially festive when baked in heart shapes.

Check out this recipe

7

Valentine’s Day Roll Cake - Pankobunny

Rolled sponge cake filled with jam or cream, sliced to reveal heart-shaped swirls. Popular in the early-to-mid 20th century, jelly roll cakes were a thrifty way to make a special holiday dessert.

Check out this recipe

8

Heart Shaped Cherry Cake

This Heart Shaped Cherry Cake recipe is tender, moist and bursting with cherry flavor. Perfect for Valentine’s Day or any special occasion!

Check out this recipe

9

Vintage Heart Cake Tutorial - Sugar & Sparrow

Learn how to make the perfect heart shaped cake with vintage piping for Valentine’s Day, birthdays, and any special occasion!

Check out this recipe

10

Pink Velvet Heart Cake — Rose Wife

White or yellow cake layered with tinted buttercream or whipped cream. A 1950s–60s party cake when home bakers experimented with food coloring for festive occasions.

Check out this recipe

Wrap-Up

Heart cakes weren’t just desserts—they were love baked into a pan. I remember walking into a church social and seeing a pink-frosted heart cake, or coming home to find grandma had whipped up a coconut-covered heart for Valentine’s. These cakes may be retro, but they’re timeless in the way they make people feel cherished. Whether you go for red velvet, strawberry shortcake, or the simplicity of chocolate fudge, these vintage heart cakes are worth bringing back to your table.

FAQs About Vintage Heart Cakes

Why were heart cakes so popular in the 50s and 60s?

Heart-shaped pans became widely available in the mid-century, and homemakers loved using boxed cake mixes to create festive shapes for holidays and parties.

Can I make a heart cake without a heart pan?

Yes! A classic trick is cutting a round cake and a square cake, then arranging them into a heart. It’s a method grandma often used before specialty pans were common.

What flavors were most popular for heart cakes?

Chocolate, red velvet, coconut, and strawberry were common mid-century flavors, with pink and red tones making them perfect for Valentine’s.

Did people decorate heart cakes differently?

Yes—pastel buttercream, coconut, jam glazes, and piped borders were the most popular mid-century decorations, often finished with sprinkles or candy hearts.

What’s the most nostalgic heart cake?

Red velvet heart cakes and coconut-covered hearts were staples of Valentine’s and anniversaries, often remembered as the centerpiece of grandma’s table.